• About

Feminism, Literature and Cake

~ Recipes for happiness

Feminism, Literature and Cake

Tag Archives: Ruth

Victim-blaming and its Victorian roots

25 Sunday Nov 2012

Posted by La Petroleuse in Feminism, Historical

≈ 1 Comment

Tags

'angel in the house', 'fallen woman', Elizabeth Gaskell, Evangelicalism, feminism, Harriet Taylor, Poor Law, Reclaim the Night, Ruth, Salvation Army, sexism, The Enfranchisement of Women, unmarried mothers, victim blaming, Victorian, William Booth

My placard for Reclaim the Night 2012

Much as I enjoyed taking back the streets in yesterday’s Reclaim the Night march, I keep having that age-old feeling of ‘I cannot believe I still have to protest this shit’. ‘Whatever we wear, wherever we go, yes means yes and no means no.’ ‘Whose bodies? Our bodies! Whose lives? Our lives!’ But the fact that we only reclaim one night a year, whilst victim-blaming, ‘slut-dropping’ and sexual violence abound in media and popular culture, speaks volumes.

It is difficult to find an acceptable explanation for the prevalence of this sexist discourse; often, it is excused with an apologetic ‘’twas ever thus’. Yet this insistence on ‘custom’ was already exposed as a non-argument by Harriet Taylor in ‘The Enfranchisement of Women’; and furthermore, as I discovered whilst researching the Victorian Poor Law Amendments, victim-blaming in its current form was, if not created, certainly officialised by the Victorian New Poor Law of 1834.

One assumes that victim-blaming must have existed prior to the Amendment Acts; however, after 1834 it was enshrined in law. Under the Old Poor Law, if unmarried mothers identified the father of their child, efforts would be made to trace him if he had absconded, and a marriage would be arranged, or the mother would be able to claim support from him.

In the campaign for the New Poor Law, economic arguments often mingled with faux morals, with campaigners insisting on the one hand that the parishes could not afford to pay a pension to unmarried women, and on the other that a pension would unjustly reward women for sinful conduct. They warned that the promise of public support would impel many unscrupulous women towards immoral conduct, since that was often the quickest way to marriage and/or an income. It was shocking, cried these moralists, that women, once fallen, should be offered a second chance.

The Victorian ‘fallen woman’

Importantly, these moral arguments placed the responsibility for sin entirely on the women. This fits in neatly with Victorian Evangelicalism and the doctrine of the ‘angel in the house’, which saw women as moral guardians, not only of themselves, but also of men. Accordingly, the New Poor Law restricted unmarried mothers’ access to support, either from the state or from the fathers of their children, in the expressed hope that this would discourage women from sacrificing their virtue for more worldly considerations.

The fact that this representation got the balance of power spectacularly wrong in the vast majority of cases, and generally only served to prevent women, once fallen, from ever re-establishing themselves, was already being pointed out during the Victorian period, by such diverse figures as the social novelist Elizabeth Gaskell and William Booth of the Salvation Army. Nevertheless, the notion of women as ladies or whores, successful guardians of their all-important virtue or dissolute and undeserving creatures, has proved shamefully persistent.

And that one of many reasons why we still march to reclaim our bodies, our lives and our right to full personhood.

7/12/12 An adapted version of this post has now appeared on the Think!Generation blog. Read it here.

Advertisements

FemLitCake

La Petroleuse

La Petroleuse

"... so the petroleuse [female incendiary] lurks behind the New Woman, waiting for the appropriate historical conditions before she emerges from her shadow" (Matthew Beaumont).

View Full Profile →

FemLitCake on Twitter

  • RT @RRRJournal: Interested in reviewing books for RRR? We're recruiting! Just send us an email at rrr@soton.ac.uk listing your research int… 14 hours ago
  • Very grateful for the lovely @BirkBeckArtsRes community! 1 day ago
  • @torcheculs @SophieCope Agreed - I think I took a week. The time off before is really important! It helped me too to do a practice run. 2 days ago
  • RT @MuseumGenerator: Hello from the Museum of Just One Pelican! Today's password is 'Emotional Mental'. Whisper that to one of our staff me… 2 days ago
  • @tavmos You'll feel worse if you don't do it? Sending good thoughts and solidarity 3 days ago
Follow @FemLitCake

Recent Posts

  • Call for Papers
  • Call for Papers for Fifty Years of Sexism: What Next?
  • Registration open: In Harkness’ London: A Symposium on the Life and Work of Margaret Harkness, 22 November, Birkbeck
  • ‘To Bridle Popularity’: The return of Victorian labour rhetoric
  • On feminism and ‘happiness’, and how individualisation of experience misses the point

Tags

'Victorian values' A City Girl Andrew Miller Anna Wheeler Annie Besant Appeal of One Half the Human Race Big Fair Bake birth control bluestockings book review cake Cambridge Caroline Criado-Perez cemetery character Charles Bradlaugh Charles Dickens Christmas Contagious Diseases Acts Costa Book of the Year Easter Eleanor Marx Elizabeth Gaskell Faber and Faber Fair Trade female activists feminism French Revolution Friedrich Engels George Eastmont Harriet Taylor historical Jane Austen Jane Eyre Jeanette Winterson Jessica Swale Josephine Butler Kazuo Ishiguro literature London Man Booker Prize Margaret Harkness Mary Barton Match Girls' Strike muffins Never Let Me Go novel NW objectification On Beauty Oranges are not the only Fruit Paris plot Pure RADA Ripper Street Sceptre sexism socialism solidarity style suffragettes theatre theatre review The Daylight Gate The Enfranchisement of Women The Remains of the Day Utopia victim blaming Victorian White Teeth witchcraft women's higher education women's writing Zadie Smith

Archives

  • November 2014
  • October 2014
  • August 2014
  • May 2014
  • February 2014
  • December 2013
  • November 2013
  • October 2013
  • September 2013
  • August 2013
  • July 2013
  • June 2013
  • May 2013
  • April 2013
  • March 2013
  • February 2013
  • January 2013
  • December 2012
  • November 2012
  • October 2012

Categories

  • Art
  • Book Review
  • Cake
  • Feminism
  • Film Review
  • Historical
  • Language
  • Literature
  • Politics
  • Theatre Review
  • Uncategorized

Meta

  • Register
  • Log in
  • Entries RSS
  • Comments RSS
  • WordPress.com
Advertisements

Create a free website or blog at WordPress.com.

Cancel
Privacy & Cookies: This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this website, you agree to their use.
To find out more, including how to control cookies, see here: Cookie Policy